We want to put an end to a political regime of exception, which favors nuclear energy and hinders the development of renewable energies

December 13th, 2018

To  Mr President of the French Republic,

The European Atomic Energy Community, or EURATOM, was established through a treaty signed in 1957 by the six member-countries of the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC). As set in Article 1, its mission is very clear. It aims at promoting the development of nuclear industry in Europe.


The ECSC was dissolved in 2002 and integrated into the European Community but, 60 years after its creation, the EURATOM treaty continues to exist outside the European Union. Maintaining such a privilege in favor of nuclear energy is as anachronistic as it is abnormal.


While EURATOM is responsible for developing powerful nuclear industries in Europe, it also sets the standards of protection against the dangers of radioactivity. The conflict of interest is blatant at the expense of the population protection.


EURATOM also constitutes a major obstacle to the development of renewable energies: by draining a considerable amount of financial aid, its existence restricts the necessary investments in the future solutions that are to be developed to preserve the future generations.


Such observations have led us to ask you, as President of the French Republic and as a member of the EURATOM Commission, to come forward as of 2019 to prepare for the termination of the treaty establishing the European Energy Community Atomic EURATOM.

Signed in 1957 and still in force, the EURATOM Treaty is

Article 1 of the Treaty establishes the EURATOM EUROPEAN ATOMIC ENERGY COMMUNITY, whose mission is to "contribute to the raising of the standard of living" in the member states by creating the "conditions necessary for the rapid formation and growth of nuclear industries".
Article 2 of the Treaty lists all that EURATOM must do to fulfill its mission: "to develop research and to disseminate technical knowledge"; "facilitate investments"; "ensure the supply (...) of ores and nuclear fuels"; "to secure broad outlets and access to the best technical means (...)", etc.

An OBSOLETE treaty
The EURATOM treaty was built on the idea that nuclear energy would bring prosperity: nuclear power had to be safe, clean and cheap.
It was already questionable at the time: 1957 was indeed the year of the Windscale accident, in England, and the Mayak catastrophe of, in the USSR. It is no longer acceptable in 2018, after Chernobyl and Fukushima, after the hundreds of millions of tonnes of radioactive waste bequeathed to future generations.

A tragic TRAP for our HEALTH
The standards of protection of the population and workers against the dangers of radioactivity are established within the framework of EURATOM while its basic mission is to develop the nuclear industry! Because of this major conflict of interest, trade-offs between economic and health interests have been, and continue to be, at the expense of our health. What would be said of a treaty establishing a European pesticide community, called "EUROPEST", which would be entrusted with defining the protection standards for Monsanto or Bayer products?

A MAJOR RISK for our environment
In normal operation, we already have radioactive waste, radioactive, chemical and thermal releases into the atmosphere, watercourses and oceans, and the recycling of contaminated metals and rubble without the knowledge of consumers.
In the event of a major nuclear accident, the life of every European citizen would be affected, millions of citizens could lose everything, hundreds of thousands of square kilometers would become uninhabitable and unfit for any culture.

By reserving preferential treatment to nuclear energy, by exempting the nuclear industry from the application of the polluter pays principle, the treaty creates distortions of competition.
By monopolizing aid and subsidies, nuclear energy dramatically reduces the money available for energy efficiency, thermal renovation and renewable energies

Euratom derogates from the normal operation of the European Union. The European Parliament has only an advisory role, not to say figurative, while the decisions taken are essential for the future of the environment and the health of all. The European citizens' initiative, which allows 1 million citizens to call on the European Commission to legislate, does not apply to Euratom and therefore to nuclear power. In addition, vital decisions for our future are based on the work of anonymous experts who do not report to anyone, even when their work is full of errors.


Share with your friends